HOME PRACTICE AREAS ABOUT US CONTACT US STATE RESOURCES CASE REVIEW
  VIDEO LIBRARY   TODAY'S LEGAL HEADLINES   LEGAL DICTIONARY   testimonials   STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS  
 
Areas of Practice
Contact Us
 

Factors Affecting Damages Awards

Nature of injury
Degree of defendant's liability
Comparative negligence
Joint and Several Liability
Plaintiff's and Defendant's credibility
Plaintiff's age
Witness testimony

Nature of injury

It stands to reason that the most important factor which will affect the amount of damages that you can recover is the nature of the injury sustained. The more serious an injury is, the higher the value of the claim. If you are suffer from a soft tissue injury, such as with whiplash or neck strain, you will not recover as much as someone who is injured more seriously, involving ligament tears, bone fractures, and nerve damage. Injuries such as whiplash and back strains are known as soft tissue injuries because they involve muscle. Although the condition can be painful, it's usually not permanent. Moreover, there is limited ability to detect this condition through medical examination, whereas bone and ligament damage is easily seen on a standard x-ray. serious injuries that can be detected with a medical examination typically receive much higher damage awards. If you have medical documentation to prove your damages, you will usually receive more compensation for your injuries.

In addition, the amount of treatment required, as well as the degree of permanency of your injuries can significantly affect the amount you will recover. Conditions which require surgery and extensive rehabilitation will present more compelling evidence of damages than injuries which heal without the need for medical intervention.
Top

Degree of defendant's liability

As noted in our materials on negligence, if the defendant is 100% at fault for causing the accident, the amount of the award will fully represent the value of the damages that are presented. There will no reduction in the award based on the defendant not being entirely at fault. For example, if you are a passenger sleeping in a car hit by a drunk driver, you are not at fault for your injury, while the defendant is completely at fault. The only issue at trial will normally be how much your damages are worth. However, if you in any way are accused of sharing responsibility for the accident with the defendant, the amount of your settlement or damage award may decrease. At , we will vigorously contest any claim that you are partially at fault for causing an accident where appropriate. Using our experience and the services of expert accident reconstructionists and investigators, we will focus on proving the fault of the defendant so that we can obtain the maximum possible settlement or verdict for you.

Top

Comparative negligence

If a plaintiff is found partially at fault for an accident, he or she has not lost his or her case altogether as long as the plaintiff could not have avoided the accident by exercising ordinary care. O.C.G.A. § 51-11-7. In Georgia, modified comparative negligence is used to calculate the degree of the plaintiff's.

Top

Joint and Several Liability

The theory of joint and several liability states that when separate and independent acts of negligence of several different persons combine to produce a single injury, the actors are considered joint tortfeasors. The plaintiff can sue these joint tortfeasors in the same action, and each individual tortfeasor (or "defendant") will be held responsible for the entire amount of damages, even if individually they were only partially at fault. The purpose of this rule is to transfer the risk that one defendant will lack the resources to pay the damages from the plaintiff to the other defendants. Mitchell v. Gibsons, 233 Ga. 453, 211 S.E.2d 744 (1975). If one defendant pays the entire judgment, the paying defendant can sue the other defendants to recover the amount of the damages that the jury found them responsible for. O.C.G.A. § 51-12-32. This is called contribution. Joint and several liability does not apply, however, if the plaintiff is found partially negligent also. In this situation, the damages will be apportioned between the plaintiff and the individual defendants in proportion to the percentage of fault attributed to them. O.C.G.A. § 51-12-33. For the plaintiff to recover from the defendants, the plaintiff’s negligence must be less than 50 percent of the defendants’ negligence combined. So if the plaintiff is 45 percent at fault, and one defendant is 40 percent at fault and another defendant is 15 percent at fault, the plaintiff can bring an action against both defendants, but joint and several liability will not apply. Union Camp Corp., v. Helmy, 258 Ga. 263, 367 S.E. 2d 796 (1988). Example: Suppose the jury awards you $100,000 in damages because you were injured in a car accident. If the jury finds the driver of the other car 60 percent at fault and the municipality 40 percent at fault, you would be able to recover the full $100,000 from either defendant under the theory of joint and several liability. If the municipality pays you $100,000 it can then sue the other driver for $60,000 under the right to contribution. However, if the jury finds you 30 percent at fault for your injuries because you were driving recklessly, finds the driver of the other car in the accident 40 percent at fault for running a red light, and finds the municipality 30 percent liable, you would only be able to recover $70,000; $100,000 minus 30 percent. You would be able to recover at most $30,000 from the municipality and $40,000 from the other driver, with no joint and several liability against either defendant.

Top

Plaintiff's and Defendant's credibility

Whether or not a jury or insurance company is likely to find you and your claim believable and of significant worth will strongly impact your claim. Can you accurately describe the events of the accident? Can you describe your injuries in detail, and in a convincing manner? Are you intelligent and well spoken? Would you make a good witness on your own behalf?

The term used to describe these intangible factors is "jury appeal." Remember that the jury members will judge both you and the defendant, and that their opinion of you will weigh into their decision on whether to award you damages, and if so, how much. It is important that all of the claims that you make are supported by the evidence, or you may quickly lose credibility with the jury.

The credibility and perception of the defendant will also affect the amount of money you receive. If the defendant in a car accident case is a 20-year-old driving a hot rod, jurors aren't likely to view the defendant favorably. This can also help a plaintiff in cases where the defendant refuses to admit fault for the accident. Exposing the "holes" in defendant’s version of the accident will damage the defendant’s credibility, resulting in higher damage awards in most cases.
Top

Plaintiff's age

Age plays a role in determining the value of a plaintiff's claim, particularly where permanency of injury is alleged. If you are a 20-year-old woman who lost her leg in an accident, then a jury will award a higher amount of damages than if you are a 80-year-old woman with the same injury. The basis for this is that the younger woman has more future pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, loss of income, and mental anguish ahead of her than does the older woman.

Top

Witness testimony

The credibility of witnesses also plays a role in affecting the amount of any recovery. This relates not only to witnesses to the accident itself, where proof of fault can be affected by their testimony, but to witnesses who are called to testify as to your damages as well. It is helpful to have credible witnesses who can clearly describe your condition before the accident to the jury, so as to assist them in understanding the change in your condition post-accident. In addition, expert witnesses often play a critical role in the outcome of any personal injury trial. In cases where there are "dueling experts", the background and professional experience of your expert is critical to establishing his or her influence over the jury.

In all matters involving personal injury it is essential that measures be taken promptly to preserve evidence, investigate the accident in question, and to file a lawsuit prior to the deadline imposed by the statute of limitations. If you or a loved one is a victim of personal injuries, call Law Office of Donald P. Edwards now at 404-526-8866 or CLICK HERE TO SUBMIT A SIMPLE CASE FORM. The initial consultation is free of charge, and if we agree to accept your case, we will work on a contingent fee basis, which means we get paid for our services only if there is a monetary award or recovery of funds. Don’t delay! You may have a valid claim and be entitled to compensation for your injuries, but a lawsuit must be filed before the statute of limitations expires.
Top

<< back



The above is not legal advice. That can only come from a qualified attorney who is familiar with all the facts and circumstances of a particular, specific case and the relevant law. See Terms of Use.

 
Copyright 2008 | Home | Contact 404-526-8866